By Patrick Bérubé
June 19, 2008 - 12:20
Warren Ellis is a genius when it comes to writing science-fiction. His vision of the near future is based on actual social changes and technologies, which makes it very credible and scary at the same time. When reading this comic book, I really felt like the future depicted could be my future. But this depiction has a major downside. While reading, I didn’t care that much about what happened to the characters. I was so interested in the concept evoked that I didn’t notice the effort made to build an interesting plot. That’s why I’m going to say that Doktor Sleepless is not about John Reinhardt but about a promised future that did not happen. And like any good science-fiction, the emphasis is not on the leading character but on the society in which he evolves and how we adapt to new technologies.
I wish I could say that I enjoyed the art as much as the story. Ivan Rodriguez does an all right job but I would have preferred something more dynamic since a lot of talking is involved in this comic book. The repetitive layout of the pages is a good example of something that could have been made more interesting only by varying the panels’ size and shape.
I don’t often recommend waiting for the trade for many reasons, but that’s what I’m going to do for this title. It is a very good monthly read but Ellis clearly writes and thinks in prevision of the trade paperback. There is almost no cut between issue, there is no recap at the beginning, characters are not reintroduced and there is not even a credits page (it’s on the inside front cover). I suspect that if he could avoid the monthly format and publish directly in graphic novel form, he would do so.
I rate this comic book 9 out 10. It’s a must for any science-fiction fan.
Rating: 9 /10